Guest reviews of Carlisle Inn Sarasota
Here you can find verified reviews our users posted on this website
Jack
2 months ago
The pools and hot tub are fantastic, perfect for relaxing after cycling the nearby trails. One drawback was the occasional noise from families, which disrupted the peaceful atmosphere.
Joseph
4 months ago
Very clean hotel with friendly staff. The heated pool is nice, but the Wi-Fi had issues. Great location near biking trails. Breakfast had good options too.
James
6 months ago
Very clean rooms, friendly staff. No bar for wine on-site.
Sylvie
6 months ago
The staff rocks at making you feel welcome. Every morning, I feast on their top-notch breakfast and enjoy the calming music that sets the mood perfectly.
The internet struggled at times, but that might not be their fault.
John
6 months ago
Immaculate hotel, immaculate breakfast with a great variety of delicious options and helpful staff who made sure everything was spotless during my stay.
Can’t fault anything about it.
Claire
7 months ago
From the moment I stepped into the lobby, I was blown away by how spotless everything was! My spacious room had a comfy bed and a fantastic shower that made my stay so relaxing. The heated outdoor pool, coupled with those delicious Amish donuts at breakfast, made for an unforgettable experience!
Strongly recommend! ❤️😍
Maureen
7 months ago
This beautiful and exceptionally clean hotel is nestled in an ideal spot, with some of the best beaches in the U.S. just a short drive away, including the breathtaking Siesta Key, and being conveniently close to various parks and local restaurants like the famous Yoder's Restaurant & Amish Village only about 650 meters away; the friendly staff and fantastic hot breakfast, featuring amazing pastries from a nearby bakery, make each stay even more enjoyable, but the hotel could benefit from offering more dining options on-site.
Edgar
10 months ago
exceptional cleanliness, fantastic breakfast, amazing staff
Marc
10 months ago
Guests at the inn can enjoy a variety of common areas with overstuffed sofas and comfy chairs for days of conversations and relaxation. The hospitality and service provided by the staff create a warm and inviting atmosphere that enhances the overall experience.
My kids wished for more kid-friendly activities.
Nathan
10 months ago
We had a rough start in our first room; it reeked of cigarette smoke despite the no-smoking signs everywhere.
Joan
10 months ago
The room was spacious, providing ample space to move around comfortably. The king-sized bed was incredibly plush, ensuring a restful night’s sleep. I appreciated the separate closet area with an extra sink, which allowed for efficient morning routines. The shower featured a detachable head with multiple settings, perfect for a refreshing experience. Large mirrors enhanced the well-lit environment. A small refrigerator was a convenient addition for storing snacks. The quiet atmosphere was ideal for relaxation.
Charles
10 months ago
The room was cozy and well-equipped, with a nice sitting area by the window that offered a good view of the surrounding area. The air conditioning worked well to keep the room at a comfortable temperature, and the heating was effective during the cooler evenings. I appreciated the free wi-fi in the rooms, as it made it easy to stay connected. The flat-screen TV provided entertainment options, although I did wish there were more channels available. The carpeted floor was a nice touch, giving the room a warm and inviting feel. One thing that could be improved is the lack of tea and coffee facilities in the room. Having the option to make a hot beverage in the morning or evening would have been a nice touch. the soundproofing in the rooms could be better, as noise from neighboring rooms was occasionally noticeable. The free toiletries provided were a nice touch, and the housekeeping service kept the room clean and tidy throughout our stay. I did notice a slight musty smell in the bathroom, which could be addressed with better ventilation.
John
10 months ago
Beautiful, clean hotel in a great location, close to downtown and beaches. Friendly staff made the experience even better. The room was spacious, with an impressive bathroom, but the beds felt a bit hard. Breakfast was good, though a little more variety would be appreciated. The oatmeal soap in the bathroom was a no-go. Free parking and a nice pool area added to the charm. Just be prepared to drive a bit if you want to explore nearby options—incredibly worth it for the wonderful ambiance and service!
Dan
10 months ago
Absolutely impressed by this hotel. The staff? Exceptionally friendly and accommodating. The rooms are spacious and stylish, providing a true home-away-from-home feeling. The on-site Amish restaurant serves phenomenal food, while the bakery pastries at breakfast are a standout. The hotel features unique gift shop items and inviting common areas, including a lovely piano. The pool and hot tub are delightful, even in cooler weather. the Wi-Fi needs improvement. Slow speeds hindered my work tasks. the water temperature in the shower was consistently too hot, despite attempts to resolve it. Still, this location offers an impressive blend of comfort and service. I’ll return without hesitation.
Jay
11 months ago
I thoroughly enjoyed my time at Carlisle Inn Sarasota. The rooms were spacious, immaculate, and featured high-quality bathrooms. The friendly staff provided great local recommendations. While the breakfast was decent, a pancake maker could enhance the experience. a charming place worth visiting again!
Nicky
11 months ago
The front desk staff was super friendly and really helpful. The breakfast had tons of choices, including waffles and sausage, which kept the kids happy.
It wasn't exactly cheap, but it was worth the price.
Anthony
1 year ago
Giant cozy spots for chatting, gaming, and naps. Biking around was mad fun, convert s , 🚴. The service was top, notch, like having personal hype, men. Breakfast buffets for royalty, y'know what I mean?
Would've been lit to have more intense pool parties, a DJ bustin' tunes by the poolside! .
Paul
1 year ago
The property was spotless, and the staff was super friendly, always with big smiles. Great location near many attractions and with cookies, tea, and coffee available all day! The fire pit lit every night was a cozy touch.
Breakfast was the same daily, and there was an issue where internet and phone services were down for a few hours. Some wished it was closer to the coast, around a 15-minute drive away.
Mark
1 year ago
From the moment we arrived at Carlisle Inn, we were impressed by the serene atmosphere and spacious rooms. The hotel was impeccably clean, and the warm, friendly staff made us feel right at home. We especially enjoyed the delicious breakfast and the convenience of having the best Amish restaurant right across the street. I'll recommend this hotel.
Jimmy
1 year ago
Great staff and spacious rooms. Wi-fi speed needs improvement.
Amy
1 year ago
I upgraded to a full breakfast buffet at the restaurant; the bed was so comfy I wanted to take it home. I loved the in, house restaurant with vegetarian and gluten, free options. The all, season pool and hot breakfast were the perfect combo!
Such a shame , absolutely nothing to complain about! .
George
1 year ago
the place is beautifully kept and super clean. the staff was so friendly and attentive, making our experience really enjoyable. the location is great, close to the beaches and shopping areas. the wide halls gave the hotel an elegant feeling, and it was nice to have the convenience of the on-site restaurant and bakery. the pool and hot tub were fantastic, and my kids had a blast. the only downside was the lack of healthy breakfast options, but everything else was wonderful.
Nothing bad to say 😊
Karen
2 years ago
Loved the spacious rooms, warm breakfast, and friendly staff. The peaceful Amish setting was a delightful surprise.
Felt cared for, nothing to complain about.
George
2 years ago
cleanliness was top-notch. carlisle inn is just a quick uber ride from siesta key village. loved the amish exhibits and traditions insight. and the surprise birthday gift for my wife was such a sweet touch!
Totally recommend
